When Being Real Sounds Suspicious

I tried to help someone online this week.

Not in a dramatic way. Not as a savior or a fixer. Just one human responding to another who sounded overwhelmed in that quiet, flattened way that doesn’t ask for much but carries a lot underneath.

A few messages in, I was told I didn’t sound real.

There was a brief tightening in my chest — that small, unmistakable moment when the ground shifts. One second you’re in a conversation, the next you’re being assessed. Then the line landed:

“This reeks of ChatGPT.”

I paused longer than I usually would. Not because I didn’t know what to say, but because I could feel that the exchange had stopped being about the words on the screen.

This wasn’t really about me.

It was about how hard it’s become to recognize sincerity online at all.

The Context of Suspicion

We’re swimming in strange waters right now. Most people I talk to are tired in ways that don’t resolve with a weekend off. They’ve been pitched to relentlessly. They’ve been emotionally targeted by algorithms that know how to sound caring while quietly guiding them somewhere else. They’ve been met with language that feels personal until it suddenly isn’t.

So when someone shows up sounding calm, measured, and genuinely interested, it doesn’t always land as safe.

Sometimes it lands as suspicious.

Not because kindness is wrong, but because manufactured kindness has been used as a tool. When that happens enough times, the nervous system adapts. It stops asking, Is this person sincere? and starts asking, Where’s the catch?

Survival Logic

That’s not cynicism. It’s survival logic.

Once that logic is activated, things can move quickly. In the exchange that prompted this reflection, the concern shifted almost in real time. First it was that I didn’t sound real. Then that I was being manipulative. Then that I must be selling something.

At no point did I ask for money. At no point did I push an offer. At no point did I argue when the tone changed.

But once suspicion takes the wheel, neutrality disappears. A calm response becomes evidence. A respectful boundary becomes evidence. Even not reacting becomes evidence.

I don’t say that with frustration. I say it with recognition. When someone is already overwhelmed, even well-intentioned help can feel intrusive — not because it is, but because it arrives when their system is already braced.

The Hallway Moment: A Lesson in Consent

This interaction reminded me of something I used to do years ago, long before the internet became part of my work.

I spent a stretch of time working in schools, some of them high-pressure environments where stress seemed to hum in the walls. During a period covering a special education classroom, I had small pockets of unstructured time. Instead of staying tucked away, I started walking the halls.

Not with a clipboard. Not with authority. Just paying attention.

It wasn’t hard to see who was carrying too much. A tight jaw. A thousand-yard stare. Someone moving quickly but not really going anywhere. Someone staring at their phone as if it were the only thing keeping them upright.

When it felt appropriate, I’d approach gently and say something like,

“This might be none of my business, and you can absolutely tell me to go away — but it looks like you’re carrying a lot right now.”

That last part wasn’t politeness. It was the whole point.

Then I’d offer something simple and optional. Five minutes. No commitment. No explanation required.

Most people said yes. Not because I convinced them, but because they were allowed to say no without consequence.

Consent changes everything. When the body senses there’s no trap, it relaxes. When choice is real, safety becomes possible.

The Cost of Doubting Calm

Online, that layer is harder to feel. There’s no tone of voice. No shared hallway. No easy way to communicate, “You don’t owe me anything.” People arrive already braced, already scanning for angles, already preparing to protect themselves.

So in the exchange that started this piece, I eventually stepped back.

Not because I was wrong. Not because I had something to hide. But because continuing to push for understanding would have turned the interaction into exactly what the other person feared. Sometimes the kindest move is disengagement without resentment.

That doesn’t mean you stop caring. It means you stop trying to be received.

There’s a cost to living in a world where sincerity and manipulation feel indistinguishable. It’s a lonely place. If every calm voice sounds rehearsed, if every offer of help sounds transactional, then the only emotions that get recognized as “real” are the dysregulated ones.

• Anger sounds authentic.
• Cynicism sounds grounded.
• Defensiveness sounds smart.

But calm gets doubted.

And that’s a loss for all of us. Calm is where people can breathe again. Calm is where clarity returns. Calm is where choice becomes available.

An Open Door

I’m not writing this to convince anyone to trust me. Skepticism makes sense right now. I understand why this happened. I understand why a door might get slammed before you even realize you’re doing it.

What I want to say, plainly, is this: I’m here. I’m real.

Even when a door gets slammed in my face, I’m still here to help. Not in a chasing way. Not in a proving way. Just present.

The work I’ve always done — whether in classrooms, hallways, or quiet online exchanges — has never been about persuasion. It’s been about noticing when someone looks like they’re carrying too much and offering a steady place to set it down, if they want to.

No pressure. No obligation. No convincing required.

If you’re someone who reacts quickly to calm right now, you’re not broken. You’re responding to the world as it is. And if you’re someone who still reaches out anyway, knowing you might be misunderstood, you’re not naïve. You’re choosing contact over certainty.

I’m here for both sides of that.

When you’re ready, we can work through it — not for my sake, but for yours. And if now isn’t the time, that’s okay too. Sometimes the most respectful thing we can do is leave the door unlocked and step back.

If you ever want a steady place to start, you know where to find me.

In the meantime, take advantage of a free tapping experience with E.M.O.

Talk to E.M.O.